Monday, September 14, 2009

Class Notes 9/14/09

The Toulmin Model of Argument:
The path to writing better essays.
  • Simply put, since the time you started learning about formal writing, you've been working off an exceptionally basic rhetorical model, especially when it comes to your thesis.
  • By now you should know that a well thought thesis is essential to the success of an essay.
  • Poor essays can usually trace their failures to an inadequate thesis.

Why This Matters?

  • Becoming a better writer isn't just about "plugging in" the correct bit- its about truly understanding why the mechanisms of an essay work the way they do.
  • You probably don't know what exactly makes a particular thesis sentence "good" or "bad" (How or why they work or don't work)
  • The Toulmin Model of Argument is a more complicated process- the thesis becomes more elaborate than the basica theses you've become used to- but mastery of this approach will enable you to write far superior essays (consistently) as well as engage in highly productive rhetorical analyses of the arguments of others.
  • It can do so because it is constructed in response to the reality of argument, it denies absolutes in favor of qualifiers (not just a yes or no answer).

Lets Agree,

  • On the idea that all verbal communication is persuasive to the same degree.
  • Therefore everything uttered is intended to get the listener to believe as the speaker believes.
  • If that is true then everything verbal can be analyzed by a model of argumentation.

Kara Schroeder

No comments:

Post a Comment